Brent is a notorious playboy but one day, his girlfriend Candy catches him with another girl named Sabrina, and the two girls break up with him. Not long after, Brent meets a goth beauty named Girlie, and he decides to flirt with the girl. Girlie later notices that she and Brent have the same birthmark and they both don't have palmlines.

However, Girlie learns from her good friend Sabrina that Brent is a player, Girlie uses her knowledge of the occult to put a spell on Brent. But Girlie and Sabrina fear that something is going wrong with the spell. The next day, Brent, Sabrina, Candy, and Girlie all wake up in separate boxes. Unable to move, they all realize they they have just been turned into small toys in a garage sale. When a girl takes them home from the garage sale, a cat chews on them and tears their limbs apart.